YouTube's copyright system is broken

  • Dipublikasikan tanggal 19 Mei 2019
  • Warner Chappell have copyright claimed 25% of my content in 2 hours and there isn't much I can do about it.
    Warner Chappell's information for research
    UK twitter - warner_chappell
    US twitter - WarnerChappell
    Facebook - warnerchappellmusic/
    Instagram - warnerchappellmusic
    My Twitter: ThatMumboJumbo
  • GameGame

Komentar • 17 519

  • Mumbo Jumbo
    Mumbo Jumbo  3 bulan yang lalu +7279

    UPDATE (as taken from my twitter)

    Things are a bit muddy.
    - I do have written permission from the artist to use the claimed song.
    - However; the song uses a sample that has been picked up by Warners content ID bot. So I am being claimed for a sample, not the song.

    I'm still hoping we can resolve this.
    And take this as a lesson from me:
    Not only should you ensure you have complete rights to the music you are using for your videos, but also ensure that you ask about any samples that have been used. Otherwise you could end up in this situation (And you wouldn't want that).
    Will do a video on Tuesday explaining. I am taking a day off tomorrow!

    • Darrell Plays
      Darrell Plays 6 hari yang lalu

      It didnt get better

    • Snarky Mark
      Snarky Mark 12 hari yang lalu

      It doesn't matter if it samples another work. If it varies by at least 15% of the original work sample, than it is a derivative work, and not their copyrighted work.

    • geared4 the truth
      geared4 the truth 15 hari yang lalu

      I'll make you a custom song you can use for whatever you want. 100% original

    • Shaun Wright
      Shaun Wright 17 hari yang lalu

      Just don't use youtube, problem solved

  • SophiePlayz
    SophiePlayz 18 jam yang lalu

    I always thought it was innocent until proven guilty but here we are.

  • voxley19
    voxley19 Hari Yang lalu

    I had a Content ID claim for a track that I downloaded from the IDclips audio library! When I e-mailed IDclips anout it, I received a terse reply basically saying hard luck. I don't use music at all in my videos now. Fortunately, the subject matter of my videos makes avoiding music easy, but I can see that this would be extremely difficult for other channels.

  • Sreenikethan I
    Sreenikethan I Hari Yang lalu

    nice shader pack

  • King Kyogre
    King Kyogre 2 hari yang lalu +1


  • Mimon Abdul
    Mimon Abdul 3 hari yang lalu +1

    That stupid warner bitch

  • DeNdReTiC
    DeNdReTiC 4 hari yang lalu

    That is complete bullshit

  • Nishaun Turner
    Nishaun Turner 5 hari yang lalu

    It should be innocent until proven guilty and if the "striker" should have a point system as well, if they falsely claim something they get a strike. Three strikes and they pay a fine or something.

  • xxjustuwuxx TM
    xxjustuwuxx TM 5 hari yang lalu

    the dislikes are from warner chappell music

  • gonor silvershot
    gonor silvershot 5 hari yang lalu

    Love your voice, hate your look.

  • 3111luke
    3111luke 5 hari yang lalu

    I feel really bad for you this should not be able to happen what a load of shi*!!

  • Saulf
    Saulf 6 hari yang lalu +1

    They hire teams of people to initiate manual copyright claims. You can search online right now and find one paying $20 an hour or more and you work from home. The best defense to keep up is to hire your own counter claim team or hope IDclips re-evaluates this issue.,IL?jid=DQa1b47c7d5f59291606d3a3b3da38ad95&

    "We collaborate with some of the most influential personalities and musicians including large gaming personalities and professional E-sports teams to Double Rainbow All The Way, one of IDclips’s most prestigious viral videos. We are at the forefront of the entertainment industry and looking for someone to join us and to become a part of the Gas family. Our Content Claiming Specialist leads our efforts to generate revenue for our clients."

  • Sam Johns
    Sam Johns 6 hari yang lalu

    While this doesn't really identify what is going on with your particular issue, it does show the scope of the problem. Go to this website for SoundExchange.!/search?artistName=Warner%20Chappel&tab=search&showReleases=0&start=0&number=100

    Warner Chappell has an ISRC number registered with SoundExchange on music they are claiming that they hold for royalties.

  • FCSΩ //FCSectorΩ
    FCSΩ //FCSectorΩ 8 hari yang lalu

    This is super unjust. This is worse than that Game Theory video with Defy.

  • Tech It Out
    Tech It Out 8 hari yang lalu

    OK there is one way you can procede. It is messy but means you will keep your monetisation. This will take a while to do. Use the seek and delete tool for the music clips in question on each vid. the claim is then made null and you regain monetisation. All the best.

  • Blue Zodiac
    Blue Zodiac 8 hari yang lalu

    MR. FLAMESPIDER052 9 hari yang lalu +1

    IDclips is focusing on the companies and on ads rather than the people who make videos that ad provides and companies use to get their name out their. Right now youtube is ignoring the people who keep them in business!
    IDclips Get Your Head Out Of Your A$$ And Focus On The People who allow you to GET INCOME!!!!

  • Charles Aiden De Leon
    Charles Aiden De Leon 9 hari yang lalu


  • Charles Aiden De Leon
    Charles Aiden De Leon 9 hari yang lalu

    Look at ProleteR's channel, and click the About Tab. It says "DON'T USE MY SONGS IN YOUR VIDEOS".

  • Ghost Unit 01
    Ghost Unit 01 9 hari yang lalu

    This is part of why I haven't uploaded to IDclips. I have concerns that I'll suddenly have strikes or something placed on me, even though I'd be under fair use. I actually do believe I had a claim placed on me at some point though I hadn't done anything wrong. There are IDclipsrs who are basically being bullied by big companies. I don't have the time, money, or patience for that. I might look around for another platform. The system is broken and just stupid.

    I wish you the best of luck with all this Mumbo. I'm sorry about this man.

  • james knight
    james knight 10 hari yang lalu

    You can go through the law route probably as you can sough the company

  • Sitting Bull Sitting Bull
    Sitting Bull Sitting Bull 10 hari yang lalu

    They are the judge jury and executioner

  • Aem111607
    Aem111607 10 hari yang lalu

    You shoulda sued them

  • EnderNator10
    EnderNator10 11 hari yang lalu

    i recommend making a patreon this way youtube and those pesky companies cant take ur money

  • Moritz Vogel
    Moritz Vogel 11 hari yang lalu

    Dam he has a nice house

  • Leo Grey
    Leo Grey 11 hari yang lalu

    You dont have a MUSTACHE!!!

  • Lloyd Share
    Lloyd Share 11 hari yang lalu

    Everyone has this, it's even worse when the people making the claims don't own the content, i've literally deleted over 100 videos with 33 million+ views

  • Megapixel Dominator
    Megapixel Dominator 12 hari yang lalu

    Warner Chappell sucks at Minecraft

  • Phil Osman
    Phil Osman 12 hari yang lalu

    Nice house

  • Aphres
    Aphres 12 hari yang lalu

    stupid stupid stupid stupid stupid
    Oh sorry wrong year

    Like if you understand that

  • Snarky Mark
    Snarky Mark 12 hari yang lalu

    This is why IDclips should not have a copyright detection system. People have legal recourse through the courts if something is a violation of their copyright. Else, it should be left untouched, and fully monetized.

  • Dan TDM
    Dan TDM 13 hari yang lalu

    logdotzip liked this video

  • Rosa Castaneda
    Rosa Castaneda 13 hari yang lalu +1

    I thought you would have a Mumbo Jumbo mustache.

  • Burger
    Burger 13 hari yang lalu

    I think they are just jealous that you have such good videos.

  • Meadow Love oxox
    Meadow Love oxox 14 hari yang lalu


  • Saunders Family
    Saunders Family 14 hari yang lalu

    Seeing him talking is weird for me... This voice belongs to a pixelated minecraft guy, not an actual human being.

  • Rage Against My Hairline
    Rage Against My Hairline 15 hari yang lalu

    WHO tf is disliking this?! Everyone should be supporting creators that get false copyright-claimed like Mumbo here. I'd love to see those people get their monthly paycheck and instead of showing how much they're getting paid, it just says "Oh, yeah, tough shit, you whistled a song for 10 minutes while you were slogging your guts out for 152 hours so we've given your pay to the person who wrote that song. And unless you can prove otherwise, you're not getting the money you worked your ass off for.
    Best idea: dislike a video that expresses that situation - really helps and shows where you stand.

  • nemobla1
    nemobla1 15 hari yang lalu

    IDclips is broken, and run by morons.

  • geared4 the truth
    geared4 the truth 15 hari yang lalu

    Don't be evil lol

  • geared4 the truth
    geared4 the truth 15 hari yang lalu

    Hmm, it's funny how the videos pertaining to copyrights and strikes always seem to have a hard time loading

  • Carlo Lim
    Carlo Lim 16 hari yang lalu

    IDclips supports these guys. They want the innocent to suffer.

  • A Dirt Block
    A Dirt Block 16 hari yang lalu

    hmmmm I've got an idea......

  • Ben Gores
    Ben Gores 17 hari yang lalu +1

    Nice house, oh yah copyright bad

  • VisioningFaun85
    VisioningFaun85 17 hari yang lalu

    Why don't you claim yourself

  • Radiated Leader
    Radiated Leader 17 hari yang lalu

    Don't forget...
    The claimant are the twats that get to decide whether your claim is true or not

  • superduper man
    superduper man 17 hari yang lalu

    So sorry to hear this. It's getting more normal to see this. But to have a blanket 400 spam claim is disgusting. IDclips treat you as guilty before investigation and ignore any urgency you have to sort it.

  • Goldenpants 123
    Goldenpants 123 17 hari yang lalu

    No shit

  • TheExiledJester
    TheExiledJester 17 hari yang lalu

    I’m so sorry man, I understand the difficulty with stupid corporate systems like this. I hope that things will get worked out very quickly.

  • The Stealthy Bomber
    The Stealthy Bomber 17 hari yang lalu

    Dear gosh the fragging fact that IDclips just lets these companies get away with it without any punishment for destroying other people's lives and stealing from them just ticks me off. I day a good way to punish them would be to ban their company from using IDclips for advertisements for 6 months and forcing them to pay back all the money they owe to the ones they falsely claimed against. Heck if you can go to jail for lying in court then you ssure should lose your advertising rights for trying to take advantage of other people and stealing their content as your own. 😡

  • C J
    C J 18 hari yang lalu

    Wait you don't have a mustache irl?

  • xMurrCattx
    xMurrCattx 19 hari yang lalu

    This is why these extra-legal systems need to be brought under some form of legal guardianship. When the government gives certain license to a big corporation to essentially be a monopoly and they put on the mantel of "platform", they take on certain public responsibilities, and those public responsibilities include preserving the traditional legal paradigms of our culture, i.e. innocent until proven guilty, and not engaging in view-point discrimination. If they can't do this, they need to lose their platform status, be declared as a editors of curated information, and feel the full weight and responsibility of these copyright claims. This will be untenable, of course, and IDclips will have to either change its ways, or shut down.

  • dakota houk
    dakota houk 19 hari yang lalu +1

    I think it's crazy you don't actually have a mustache

  • RedSkysAreOnFire
    RedSkysAreOnFire 19 hari yang lalu

    i deleted most of my video's because a polish company claimed to have copyright on them, and then disputed the fact that I could prove that they didn't because all content was made under a creative commons license they just didn't want to know and just wanted all the revenue. So I just deleted the ones they could have made money from just to stop them because youtube just sided with the content revenue scammers.

  • Avymmm Plays
    Avymmm Plays 19 hari yang lalu

    ... Sue them? Idk, after all, they probably have done the to others and are currently doing this to others. If this was out in court, I'm P sure they'd lose.

  • Danny Luchtenveld
    Danny Luchtenveld 19 hari yang lalu

    I hope that it gets resolved quickly

  • Eli Versus Politics
    Eli Versus Politics 19 hari yang lalu

    But but but we need copyright laws so that some millionaire fat fuck in a suit and tie can afford his third private jet! Don't you care about porky?

  • Callie
    Callie 19 hari yang lalu

    Hey buddy wheres your mustache? Huh? Did Grian maybe take it? Just curios thats it....

  • Sembreon
    Sembreon 19 hari yang lalu

    What even is Warnee Chappel?

    WOLDERIONER 20 hari yang lalu

    This is what pewdiepie have been trying to say for so long

  • D - BAP
    D - BAP 20 hari yang lalu

    AFK Automated copyright claim farm.